This recipe is a variation on the
Vietnamese Chicken Noodle Soup that is one of my favorite comfort foods. Whenever I am sick or otherwise down, there are few dishes that I find as satisfying as my mom's Vietnamese Chicken Noodle Soup (or my own version of the dish). And after working like a maniac all month I was ready for some comfort food. So I suggested my soup. But Alex was more interested in trying something new so we decided to make a similar recipe from
Into the Vietnamese Kitchen that I had been meaning to try. And somehow we had everything we needed. That almost never happens when I randomly suggest a recipe at 8:00 pm.
After eating the soup, I decided that this soup is more of a winter soup, while my mom's soup strikes me as more summery. The flavors in my mom's soup are a little lighter and fresher, whereas I thought the broth here was somehow deeper and a little less bright. Part of reason that this broth lacks the freshness and brightness of the other soup is that we essentially used boxed chicken stock, fish sauce, and some soaking liquid from the dried mushrooms as the broth. And dried mushrooms are kinda deeply umami and heavy. In my mom's soup I tend to throw in various aromatics (lemongrass, shallot, ginger are typical) in a base of water with some chicken bouillon mixed in. I tend to throw some fresh shiitakes in while the broth is simmering, which I prefer to the reconstituted dried mushrooms. Another reason that this soup wasn't as bright and fresh was that we were ran out of fresh cilantro. I think that a nice sprinkle of cilantro would have really done something for the dish. To try and brighten the broth up a little Alex and I ended up squeezing in some fresh lime juice, which I thought really helped to give the broth a little more depth of flavor. For whatever reason, I like the lighter broth better. It wasn't that this broth lacked flavor, it was just that I preferred the other. And a certain amount of that can be attributed to nostalgia - there are certain dishes that my mom used to make that I will forever prefer over all other versions. This might just be one of them. But, one thing that I really did like about this soup was that the chicken was poached and then shredded. I really liked the texture of the shredded chicken over the chunks of sliced chicken I usually throw in. I think I will appropriate that element from this recipe for future chicken soup recipes. Alex liked the rich, earthy flavor of the dried mushrooms, so maybe we will make Vietnamese Chicken Noodle Soup in the future with both fresh and dried mushrooms. While I prefer my mom's recipe for soup over this one, I really like that this recipe gave me something to think about (and ways to improve upon her recipe although I won't tell her that) when I make my mom's recipe in the future. And I am intrigued by the idea of combining my favorite elements of the two recipes (with some homemade chicken stock) to come up with something better and greater than either recipe could be on its own.
Recipe after the jump!