
While in Aruba I got in a conversation with friends about how I am intimidated by hollandaise. I'm not really sure at this point why I stay away from hollandaise in my kitchen, I just know that I have yet to make eggs benedict at home, because it would require me to make hollandaise sauce. I've always heard that hollandaise is hard to make - it breaks, you have to whisk it by hand over a saucepan of gently simmering water, etc. Then I realized, if you're going the home cook version, you can also make hollandaise in a blender. Genius! But when I told Alex that we were going to make the hollandaise for our eggs benedict in a blender he shamed me into doing it the old-fashioned way. Well, really he shamed himself into it because I refused to be the one standing over the saucepan of gently simmering water whisking away. Instead, Alex had to whisk the eggs into submission while I commentated. And for the record, the first batch of hollandaise we made broke. So we had to start over. See? I had reason to stay away - hollandaise is finicky! But in the end, particularly once you know what you are looking for, it's not hard to make. Basically, we learned that the hollandaise goes from thin, to thick, to thickest - almost the consistency of aioli or homemade mayonnaise. Stop once you get to that really thick point, otherwise your sauce might break and end up a buttery, liquidy mess. It just requires some knowledge, babysitting and arm muscle.
I decided to top my eggs benedict with asparagus and prosciutto rather than smoked salmon, or the more traditional ham. And I decided to serve it on toasted crusty sourdough from Amy's Breads. Alex and I both agreed that we loved the sourdough in our version of eggs benedict. It soaked up the runny egg yolks and the hollandaise sauce without getting mushy, and it gave the dish great flavor. Also, this hollandaise was lighter (overall it was just less heavy and rich) and more lemon-y than most I have tasted. I know a lot of recipes call for either vinegar or lemon juice and I have to say that with the asparagus I loved the noticeable lemon flavor of our hollandaise. The proscuitto added just the right note of rich, salty, porky goodness - without it I think the dish would have been missing something. As much as I loved this dish, I think we will probably only make it once every 6 months or so because it requires so many pots and pans and a good amount of effort. But it was delicious.
Recipe after the jump!